Welding is a fantastic way to join metal parts, but it’s not without its challenges. One of the tricky things about welding is that it can leave behind something called residual stress. These are internal stresses that stay in the metal even after the welding is done and everything has cooled down. If you’ve ever welded something and later found that it warped or cracked, residual stress might be the culprit.
How Welding Affects Stress in Metal (and How We Can Predict It)
So, what causes this stress? When you weld, the area around the weld gets extremely hot and expands. But the cooler parts of the metal around it don’t expand as much, which creates tension. Then, as the weld cools, it tries to shrink back, but the surrounding metal holds it in place, locking in that stress. Over time, this can weaken the metal or cause it to fail.
In this article, we’re going to look at three key things that affect how much residual stress is left behind after welding:
- Heat input (how much energy you put into the weld).
- Welding speed (how fast you move the welding tool).
- Welding method (the type of welding process you use, like laser or arc welding).
We’ll also talk about how a computer program called Abaqus can help us predict and understand these stresses without having to do a bunch of real-world tests. Let’s dive in!
Contact our consulting team.
1. Heat Input: Turning Up the Heat (and the Stress)
What is heat input? Think of heat input as the amount of energy you’re pumping into the weld. It’s like how much fuel you’re giving to a fire—the more fuel, the bigger and hotter the fire gets. In welding, more heat input means the area around the weld (called the heat-affected zone, or HAZ) gets larger because more of the metal is heated up.
How does it affect stress? When you use more heat, a bigger chunk of the metal gets hot and expands. Then, when it cools, that large area tries to shrink but is held back by the cooler parts around it. This tug-of-war creates more residual stress. So, generally, more heat input leads to more stress.
But there’s a twist: if you use a lot of heat, the stress might spread out over a wider area, which could make it less intense in any one spot. It’s like spreading butter over toast—more butter covers more area, but it’s thinner. Still, in most cases, higher heat input means higher stress.
2. Welding Speed: Fast and Furious (or Slow and Steady)
What is welding speed? This is simply how fast you move the welding tool along the joint. Imagine walking with a paintbrush—faster means less paint in each spot, slower means more.
How does it affect stress? If you weld faster, you’re not spending as much time heating each part of the metal, so less heat is put into each spot. This usually means a smaller heat-affected zone and less residual stress. It’s like quickly passing a hairdryer over your hair—it doesn’t get as hot as if you hold it in one place.
However, there’s a catch: welding too fast can create very steep temperature changes, which might cause stress in a different way. But overall, faster welding tends to reduce the amount of residual stress.
3. Welding Method: Choosing Your Weapon
What is the welding method? There are different ways to weld, like laser welding (which uses a focused beam of light) or arc welding (which uses an electric arc to melt the metal). Each method heats the metal differently.
How does it affect stress? The method you choose changes how the heat is applied:
- Laser welding is like using a precision tool—it heats a very small area very quickly. This can create high stress in that tiny spot because the temperature changes so fast.
- Arc welding heats a larger area more slowly, so the stress might be spread out more, but it depends on how much heat you’re using.
- Some methods, like submerged arc welding, use a blanket of flux to slow down cooling, which can help reduce stress.
So, the type of welding you pick can make a big difference in where and how much stress is left in the metal.
Simulating Weld Parameter Effects in Abaqus
- Goldak Double-Ellipsoid Model for arc welding (e.g., GTAW, GMAW), which distributes heat in a semi-ellipsoidal shape ahead and behind the weld.
- Gaussian or Conical Model for laser welding, representing a focused heat source.
- Boundary Conditions: Apply convection and radiation losses to the environment.
- Output: Obtain the temperature history across the model.
- Mechanical Analysis:
- Import the temperature history as a thermal load.
- Define mechanical boundary conditions to prevent rigid body motion (e.g., fix one end).
- Compute stresses and strains due to thermal expansion and contraction.
- Output: Residual stress distribution after cooling.
- Execution:
- Run the thermal analysis first, then the mechanical analysis sequentially using Abaqus’ coupled temperature-displacement capability or separate steps with data transfer.
Simulating Specific Parameters
- Heat Input:
- Q=η⋅PQ
How to Model: In the heat source model (e.g., Goldak), heat input is controlled by the power parameter ( Q ) (in watts), adjusted for process efficiency (e.g.,
- Simulation Steps:
- Define the heat flux in Abaqus using the *DFLUX subroutine or built-in heat source options.
- Keep welding speed constant and vary ( Q ) (e.g., 500 W, 1000 W, 1500 W).
- Analyze how changes in ( Q ) affect the HAZ size and residual stress magnitude in the mechanical analysis results.
- Simulation Steps:
- Welding Velocity:
- How to Model: Welding speed determines the rate at which the heat source moves along the weld path. In Abaqus, this is implemented by defining the heat flux position as a function of time (e.g.,
x=v⋅tx =, where ( v ) is velocity.
- Simulation Steps:
- Specify the weld path (e.g., a line along the x-axis).
- Vary the velocity ( v ) (e.g., 2 mm/s, 5 mm/s, 10 mm/s) in the heat source motion definition.
- Compare the resulting temperature profiles and residual stress distributions to observe the effect of speed on HAZ and stress.
- Simulation Steps:
- Welding Method:
- How to Model: Different welding methods are simulated by selecting an appropriate heat source model and parameters:
- GTAW/GMAW: Use the Goldak double-ellipsoid model with parameters for width, depth, and front/rear distribution.
- Laser Welding: Use a Gaussian or conical heat source with a narrow focus.
- SAW: Adjust efficiency and possibly model insulation effects via boundary conditions.
- Simulation Steps:
- Define the heat source shape and parameters in Abaqus (e.g., via *DFLUX subroutine).
- Incorporate method-specific details, such as element birth and death techniques for molten pool simulation in arc welding (activating elements as the weld progresses).
- Run simulations for each method and compare residual stress patterns.
Practical Considerations in Abaqus
Meshing: Use a fine mesh near the weld path to capture steep temperature and stress gradients, with coarser elements farther away to reduce computation time.
- Validation: Compare simulation results with experimental data (e.g., X-ray diffraction measurements of residual stress) to ensure accuracy, adjusting material properties or heat source parameters as needed.
- Advanced Features: Utilize Abaqus user subroutines like *DFLUX for custom heat flux definitions or *UMAT for complex material behavior if standard models are insufficient.
Conclusion
- Heat Input: Higher values typically increase residual stresses by enlarging the HAZ; simulate by varying heat source power ( Q ).
- Welding Velocity: Faster speeds generally reduce residual stresses by lowering heat input; simulate by adjusting the heat source’s travel speed.
- Welding Method: Influences stress via heat source shape and cooling rate; simulate by selecting appropriate heat source models (e.g., Goldak for arc, Gaussian for laser).
- Using Abaqus, these effects can be systematically studied by defining a moving heat source in a thermal analysis, followed by a mechanical analysis to compute residual stresses, with parameter variations applied to isolate each factor’s impact. This approach provides a powerful tool for understanding and optimizing welding processes to manage residual stress effectively.
